The Best Tasting Pizza in Myrtle Beach

The first thing you will notice about coming to Myrtle Beach is the diverse range of restaurants to choose from. They have oceanfront, Calabash buffets, Seafood, and luckily some of the best-tasting pizza in Myrtle Beach.

Since the influx of “new transplants” have settled in their new homes, most are eager to find a good New York Style Pizza to sink their teeth into. Pizzeria owners who have roots in the big apple have also brought their flair & ‘saucy’ sauce of New York-style pizza to the Grand Strand.

Reviews from customers who have tried the best-tasting pizza in Myrtle Beach on Trip Advisor.

AJ's Pizza in Myrtle Beach
AJ’s Pizza in Myrtle Beach

AJ’s Pizza  – Location: 5917 N. Kings Hwy. Myrtle Beach

If you’re looking for a new twist in Pizza, AJ’s is the place. Have you ever tried a bacon cheeseburger pizza? Reviewers boast about the flavor and added that the pizza was “excellent & would highly recommend”.

Pizza Town– Located on 1867 Hwy 544 in Conway, SC

Planning to go to a college football game at CCU?  THE place to stop by for a quick bite is Pizza Town. Famous for a nice thick Sicilian slice- the crust is the crispiest! They have a small sit-down seating area but mostly is for take-out. They always have great deals even on the weekends.

Pizza Town Coupon
Pizza Town Coupon

Vicini’s Restaurant and Pizza –  Location: 5001 N. Kings Hwy. Myrtle Beach

This restaurant is cozy, intimate with a family-style atmosphere. Known for its crispness and sweet sauce. Some claim “it’s the best they have ever had”!  Visitors keep coming back.

Scatori’s Pizzeria – Location:   1399 South Commons Dr. Myrtle Beach

Very cheesy pizza- never stingy. Has an impeccable reputation for excellent dishes, and huge portions. Also, the best-tasting pizza in Myrtle Beach- the locals have been coming to Scatori’s for years!  A hidden gem for sure!

Michael’s Pizza, Pasta and Grill – `1701 N. Kings Hwy. Myrtle Beach

One reviewer on Trip Advisor claims it’s the “best-kept secret in Myrtle Beach”.  Food comes out hot and fresh tasting. The stuffed pizza is chock full of fresh pepperoni, sausage, bacon – a meat lovers delight! This item is a top seller!

Hot Tomato– Located 406 21 Ave North

Hot Tomato serves up NY-style brick oven pizza and other Italian meals. Customers on Trip Advisor claim, that “the food and service are awesome!!”

 Unique pizza pies are available. Like chicken on your pie?

Pizza of the Month is the Korean BBQ Chicken Stir Fry- how about that for Korean infusion? Your taste buds will be exploding!

Pizza of the month- Hot Tomato in Myrtle Beach
Pizza of the month- Hot Tomato in Myrtle Beach

Dough Boys NY Style Pizzeria – Located at 2696 Beaver Run Blvd Ste E. Myrtle Beach

Let the people speak for themselves- “Great pizza at a good price! Slight crispy outside and chewy inside. Perfectly cooked with excellent sauce, cheese and toppings” and “Can’t say enough about this amazing establishment!! Been coming to them for years for comfort in their food like no other!”  (Trip Advisor Review). Need we say more??

Gino’s Real New York Pizza – Located at 3521 Belle Terre Blvd Forestbrook Village, Carolina Forest, MB

The owner Gino is from Astoria so he knows his pizza! New York Themed-style restaurant- just stop in and visit and have a crispy slice. Enjoy the scenic framed pictures of New York City landmarks and subway maps! According to Gino, what makes a good pizza is a sturdy stiff crust, and should stand up to the toppings. See for yourself!

Gino's Pizzeria in Carolina Forest
Gino’s Pizzeria in Carolina Forest

Causeway Pizza – Located at 211  Atlantic Blvd Garden City

If you’re staying in Myrtle Beach you will have to travel down south a few miles. It is definitely worth it! Their pizza is hands down one of the best-tasting pizzas in the Myrtle Beach area. Is it the sauce, the brick over, or the crust? They put garlic butter on the pizza as it’s cooking, even on the crust, the sauce is sweet tasting. We like to eat ours right on the pier- just walk on down and enjoy the sights.

Causeway Pizza in Garden CIty, SC
Causeway Pizza in Garden City, SC

Coast Pizza– 9660 N Kings Hwy. Myrtle Beach, 

Opened several years ago, Coast Pizza has quickly gained popularity as the best-tasting pizza in Myrtle Beach. The owners have succeeded in starting an eatery that has good quality food- as mentioned on their website. So if you are looking for a different take on pizza it’s strongly suggested to pop in. The latest specialty pies include the Trenton Tomato Pie & the mustard pie- yum!!

Read this Post on more Restaurants in Myrtle Beach

Thanks for reading this post!

Kathy T.


Kathy publishes a community-based blog about the Myrtle Beach area. Focusing on new businesses and helping others by getting involved in community projects for the needy (including homeless pets). She also writes about unique destinations, trending places, and new job opportunities.

Coastal Carolina University Life